ISBN 9781876044251
Published 1998
75 pgs
$22.95
The
Hanging of Jean Lee book sample
Back to top
Chronology
Personal Pages
Birth Column
Mum’
s
Little Helper
Interrogation
Skipping Rhyme
Sewing Hints
Confession
A Chatswood Chapter
School Report (1928)
Behind the Shelter Shed
Dear Diary (c. 1931)
A Bun in the Oven
Reportage (The Sun)
Bedroom Burial
Dear Diary (1934)
Entertainment Section
Saturday Arvo
Mug Shot I
Girl Meets Boy
It’
s a Girl!
I Have a Baby
Reportage (The Argus)
Leaving Ray Brees
Dear Diary (1941)
You Stalker
Advertisement
Living it Up
Go West Young Woman
Learning the Trade
In Defence of the Working Girl
Studio Portrait (c. 1944)
Crime Supplement
An Explanation of Sorts
Bobby Jean
Headlines (The Herald)
The Badger Game
Divorce File
Jilly’
s Song
Spring Carnival Fever
The University Hotel
Dear Diary (1949)
Murder at Mallow House
Coroner's Report
Trial
Reportage (The Age)
Courtroom Kiss
Counter-Appeal
Death Notices
Mug Shot II
Solitary
Schoolyard Chant
Note to a Daughter
Cell Talk
Pentridge Poem
Ode to my Family
Dear Diary (1951)
Final Night
The Hangman’
s
Handbook
Fly Away Jean
Back to top
Reviews
Something
is Always Ushering Us: Recent Australian Poetry
Alan Gould
Quadrant,
No. 364, Vol. XLIV,
No.
3, March 2000
A thoroughly ill-written book on the HSC syllabus can suggest a
committee
has been successfully lobbied - one hears the gossip. Equally, its
members
may simply be ill-read in Australian poetry. Either way, the damage is
the
same when a wideawake Year 12 student, coming from the superb
craftsmanship
of Wilfred Owen or Judith Wright to the prosy inconsequence of
Westbury’s
‘These Days’ or ‘After the
Deadline’ [
Mouth
to Mouth], and finding in all that accessibility not a
shadow of
insight
or entrancement, asks, ‘And do I also count
these with what is
wise, moving and
good
in poetry?’ Somewhere, I suggest, a curriculum committee
needs
sufficient
respite from its sessions to form its taste in what can and
can’t pass
as
a poem.
That committee might do well to place
The
Hanging of Jean Lee (Black Pepper) before its students,
for
Jordie
Albiston’s verse novel is a thoroughly compelling, incisive
and finely
wrought
sequence of poems which probes the fate of a particular woman, Jean
Lee,
hanged in 1951 at Pentridge for her part in a murder.
Stories of this kind, whether in verse or a newspaper column, have a
characteristic
momentum, one that is governed by the reader’s grim
foreknowledge of
how
things will end. This momentum entails an emotional response, in part
dread
for the narrowing of a life towards the ghastly and clinical details of
the
scaffold, in part a furtive excitement as to how
this character fell
towards
this
fate, how a life entered a
vortex.
Elizabeth Bishop’s ‘The Burglar of
Babylon’, and some of the Icelandic
‘outlaw’
sagas have a similar fatalist momentum.
With an acute eye for period and sociological accuracy, Albiston takes
us
through Jean Lee’s thirty-two years from birth notice to
execution.
There
are the skipping rhymes of childhood, domestic frugalities, the
experience
of church, 1930s Sydney and the building of its bridge. Into this
everyday,
and with telling constraint, Jean’s depressive episodes and
her later
rages
are introduced. Indeed Jordie Albiston’s constraint is
impressive, for
Jean
Lee’s story doubtless held opportunities for polemics whereby
a present
sensibility
punishes the past for being sexist, judicially brutal, whatever. But
this
poet is an artist. Her focus is steadily upon the vivid individuality
of
her protagonist. It is Jean Lee who reacts characteristically against
her
treatment by the menfolk in her life, who denies God and church as her
personality compels, who goes with piteous realism to the gallows. The
moral underpinning
of the story is the surer for this fidelity to character and detail,
and
so much more accomplished than the best-seller collections I have in
mind
in my third paragraph above.
But this verse novel compels, not only for what may be visualised, but
also
for what may be heard. Albiston’s ear is as finely tuned to
childspeak
as
it is to Australian working-class argot of the 1930s and 1940s.
Throughout
the story’s four chapters there is a rhythmic arrangement
similar (as I
understand
it) to rap music where rhymes are hidden within lines but where the
momentum
of the narrative falls towards them, sometimes with the effect of
nursery
rhyme, sometimes with a tolling of finality, sometimes giving an aural
mimesis
of the tensions in Jean Lee’s psyche. Here, in the early
1940s, she is
sloughing
a husband:
You
licker
you stickler you fixer
of
rhymes You know
how you
mangle
me do it
keep doing it
do it
again You’re
the genius
of undoing
love the shade on
my shadow you double the
load
I lug through the minute
the hour ...
...Get
off
my future
You’re hurting my
heart
you monkey
you husband
you florid false
start I don’t like
the way you sing in my
choir
and I hate the sound of
your part.
Finally, Jordie Albiston shows great art in structuring her story. For
all
that it proceeds chronologically, individual poems are intruded into
the
childhood and subsequent sections, foreshadowing Jean Lee’s
fate and
having
the effect of gradually straitening the life in a way parallel to her
depressive
episodes and the paltriness of her criminal activity prior to the
murder.
The arrangement is thus best comprehended as a musical one of themes
being
anticipated, repeated, varied and integrated. A finely made novel
requires
a fine control of time, and
The
Hanging
of Jean Lee is a case of finely judged premonitions and
flashbacks.
The result is a most convincing story and a most resonant work of art.
I
hope it brings the poet and her publisher prosperity and the gratitude
of
thousands.
Back to top
The Hanging
of Jean Lee
Karen Attard
Cordite,
No. 6-7, 2000
The Hanging of Jean Lee
is
based
on fact. Lee, along with Robert Clayton and Norman Andrews, was
convicted
in 1951 of the torture and murder of William (Pop) Kent in his boarding
house
bedroom. All three were executed in that same year. Jean Lee was the
last
woman hanged in this country and the only woman executed in Australia
during
this century. The case was a cause celebre, minutely and sensationally
reported
in contemporary newspapers. Albiston has acknowledged her debt to the
media
by entitling the four sections of the book ‘Personal
Pages’,
‘Entertainment
Section’, ‘Crime Supplement’ and
‘Death Notices’. There are also
several
found poems in the collection which consist either of headlines or
actual
reportage.
Some of the poems are written in the third person but many employ
Lee’s
voice,
although her mother and the executioner are each allowed to speak in a
single
poem. Pop Kent is conspicuously silent, unless you count his wounds -
meticulously
enumerated in ‘Coroner’s Report’ - as a
message written on his body, a
silent
record of abuse. Any contemporary exploration of a violent crime must
negotiate
the dichotomy between acknowledging the victim and an attempt to
understand
how the perpetrator came to be as they are. To give Pop Kent a voice
would
have been one solution to this dilemma but it wouldn’t have
reflected
the reality of the trials. The dead don’t speak.
Albiston has chosen a more subtle approach.
The Hanging of Jean Lee
begins with
Lee’s
childhood:
I am
four
years old
I can reach the front
door get
letters from the
letter-box and
bring in the milk go buy
the
paper and clean up
what’s spilt
‘Mum’s Little Helper’
But the reader’s expectation of a simple linear progression
from birth
to
death is disrupted by the poems ‘Interrogation’ and
‘Confession’
written
in the voice of the adult Lee and inserted amongst the skipping rhymes,
dolls
clothes and diary entries of the first section. The innocence of
childhood
and some of the formative events that may have precipitated
Lee’s later
rage
are mediated by the presence of her victim. Albiston doesn’t
let us
forget
that a man was brutally murdered. His voice may be absent but the
violence
done to him isn’t:
Yes I
cut
the old boy with a small pocket-knife
though it
wasn’t particularly him Yes
I
burned
his skin with some
Players Bobby
bought
beat
and bashed till he threw
the towel in
I
s’pose
I sort of done my block
hit him with
a
bottle
and a piece of wood and
then he fell
over
‘Confession’
But ‘Confession’ also contains echoes of the child
who did ‘what was to
be
done’ when she attempts to take sole blame for the murder
‘I’m who you
/
want I did the old man it was me and me alone’.
Mum’s little helper
can’t
clean up this mess.
The hanging of Lee, as the title suggests, is central to this
collection,
the point to which all else leads. The prisoner is given into the hands
of
the executioner, and so is the poem:
...I
tie
her carefully to
the chair that she may
feel held as
she falls Adjust the
hood and get
the nod then let the
trapdoor go
‘The Hangman’s Handbook’
The roots of the word execute lie in the Latin
ex-sequi: to follow
out, pursue,
perform.
In
The Hanging of Jean
Lee
Jordie
Albiston has achieved all this.
Back to top
‘Cliff
Hanging’ & ‘Gliding’
The
Hanging of
Jean
Lee
Judy Johnson
Ulitarra,
No. 15, 1999
When I started reading
The
Hanging
of
Jean Lee, I was reminded of a comment made by Peter Boyle
a few
years
ago that ‘powerful facts and stories are not in themselves,
poems’.
This
statement concerned what he had judged to be the disturbing trend of
some
poets to prop up their work with sensational subject matter. I mention
this
not to accuse Jordie Albiston of ‘propping’, but to
offer her writing
as
an example of how accomplished poetics and sensational story line can
come
together to create something memorable.
The Hanging of Jean Lee
is a
series
of poems about the life and times of Jean Lee, a woman I confess I knew
nothing
about. The book spans thirty two years from Jean’s birth in
1919,
through
her growing up, becoming enmeshed in a life of prostitution and petty
crime,
up until her hanging in 1951 for her part in the murder of aging
bookmaker
William (Pop) Kent in Carlton. The book is divided into four
newspaper-like
sections: ‘Personal Pages’,
‘Entertainment Section’, ‘Crime
Supplement’,
and ‘Death Notices’. To add extra illumination to
events, several
newspaper
articles are interspersed between the poems.
The most intriguing part of the collection is Albiston’s
poetic
exploration
of the mind of Jean Lee. Although there is a chronology of events
listed
near the front of the book, the poet has chosen not to use a linear
narrative
to string the poems together. Instead, she dislocates the storyline -
time
and perspective leap deftly forwards, backwards and sideways.
The narrators of the poems are Jean herself, her mother, and several
other
characters as the appear in the unfolding drama. In
‘Mum’s Little
Helper’
the speaker is Jean at four years old, telling us
my job
is helping my
Mum
When
she gets tired and has
her lie-
down I wash up mop lino
do
what’s to be
done I run around
tidying
up
The next poem leapfrogs twenty six years to where Jean in
‘Interrogation’,
referring to Pop Kent’s murder says
Norm
and
me killed him while Bobby
walked up Lygon
Street I squeeze out
a tear so the mongrels
will know what
betrayal and fear can do
to the girl.
This juxtaposition of innocence and experience is a powerful tool
Albiston
uses often and to great effect. Like the
‘Innocents’ in Blake’s songs,
Jean’s
early childhood seems unremarkable and unthreatening. The fact that she
deviates
so far from the straight and narrow creates the tension of unanswered
questions.
There are foreshadowings of how Jean will end up, however. In
‘Sewing
Hints,’
her mother tells us of young Jean’s dolls:
See
how
she
sticks
in old dress-pins
for
pearls a globe
on each
lobe
In a later poem, ‘Bedroom Burial’, Jean dismembers
the same dolls:
plucks
limbs like
petals
he loves me not
and grasping a
head in each adult
hand Snaps it back
Her growing sociopathic detachment is at its height in
‘Confession’
where,
speaking of the murder, she says
Yes
I
cut the old boy with a small pocket-knife
though it
wasn’t particularly him
God appears, but he seems more an adversary than a comfort. In
‘Dear
Diary
(1934)’, Jean says
I will
kill Him
but
first
I will force
Him to crawl through
the valleys and shadows
scrawled over my soul
I will teach Him the
scriptures from inside
of me
Despite her anger and obvious depression, Jean is clearly not a
monster.
In the tender ‘Jilly’s Song’, she says of
her daughter
When
she
cried I was
burned
a
wire
on each nipple a fire in my
womb a start-up spark to
the heart.
Albiston has a particular gift for conjuring immediacy through unerring
colloquial
voice and a historian’s concern with re-creating time and
place
accurately.
At no point in this powerful collection is there a sense the poet is
intruding
on the poems. Instead, she allows them to tell their own story.
It’s an
un-putdown-able
read.
Back to top
Jason Sweeney on The Hanging of Jean Lee
Jason Sweeney (poet)
Sidewalk,
No. 2, Summer 1999
(pgs 28-29)
Process: to live inside the mind, a
world contained, unresolved lives, things scattered,
remnants, maybe a murder will rate a lost soul to stardom, complicated,
an historical name, Jean Lee, forged dentity, absent, a voice to speak
it/mediate (ghost writer): poet, Jordie Albiston. A book like a scrap
journal, photos and files, poem-biog.
From domestic ideals,
daydreams, god/God, betrayed by prayers and
compressed
by Our Father Which art [‘...There is no God... no more
Bonnie or
Clyde’ - ‘Interrogation’] or
[‘When I neet God
I will kill Him...’ - ‘Dear Diary
(1934)’], swamped
with or by guilt. Choices made to revile supposed heroes. Jean Lee:
heroine in somebody else’s eyes. Viewing character
statements,
evidence of a life in descent, progress made, toward death. Albiston
nakes no claims, she surveys and samples (like UK sound artist,
Scanner, who maps cities by documenting the voices of people, jacking
moments/movements, splicing together), it’s a surreal listory
written in disturbing clarity, making attempts to link events, like
watching a television through incessant static. No judgements, fears
remain (of what can not be left) alone. A cut-up. A killing. A girl
(Lee) painted in lucid text with a razor dipped in blood. To a page. A
trial. Crimes out of sync, no confession to sanctify the
sinner, pure
admissions, statements, articles, items, witnesses,
appropriations of news reports, serving (somehow) a narrative, a
sentence. Jean went too far [‘I sort of done my block... I
was
joing my job’ - ‘Confession’).
Albiston parallels and shifts stuff around. Makes reference.
Textual stains. Metaphors/origins for the grime of Jean Lee’s
future gutters. A forgotten (Australian) figure archived, a pathway
leading to an execution for a dark soul. No bright impressionistic
landscapes here, only worn, dirtied canvases, complex in detail. Words
cite ‘fact’ [‘...Lee is the first woman
to be hanged
at this prison’ - ‘Reportage (The Sun)’].
The
subject’s final sight: Pentridge. A scene extracted from
In Cold Blood.
That kind of movie. That kind of book. Images, I am reminded... and
shattered. A sequence of events leading up to, before and after, the
effect. Albiston’s ‘Mug Shot I’
and ‘Mug
Shot II’ are evidence of identity trauma. A sick portrait of
a
Lee losing it, on her way down, beyond retribution. Losing children, a
lost child, all measured in regret (perhaps) or delusion (I figure) and
guilt (probably), in public domain, sensational. Her death (a bible
hung with her) channelled into/through poems, indexed by title, name,
author, subject, Jean, Jordie, Albiston, Lee. Spirit needs a tool.
Jean: her name is alive in Jordie. And the book is framed. Executed,
read, relevant. Making
The
Hanging of Jean Lee an epic tragedy, a libretto for a
fucked up life. Reduced to an object, on display, for the record.
Back to top
Poetry
Poets struggle with
experience
The
Hanging of
Jean
Lee
Julian Croft (academic)
Antipodes,
Vol. 13, No. 2,
December 1999
Decorating the cover of
Jack
Hibberd’s
first
collection of poetry [
The Genius of Human Imperfection]
(Hibberd
is better known as a prolific playwright and occasional novelist) is a
George
Grosz drawing of one of his embodiments of Weimar decadence. And broken
across
the cover of Jordie Albiston’s volume is a collage of a
photograph of
murderer
Jean Lee being taken to court in 1950...
The unitary view of the satirist sure of the evils that surround him
contrasted
with the fragmentary identities that make the individual in the late
twentieth
century are neatly contrasted. The two views come from poets separated
by
thirty years and very different world-views.
Hibberd
writes with the weight of the past and from the Olympian heights of
certainty.
Albiston writes from the inside of a consciousness that does not
understand
what is going on, but tries to define where she is by her relationships
with
her family, her lovers, and her daughter. There is nothing new about
the
multi-vocality of the poet’s speaking position: Shakespeare
did it in
the
sonnets (perhaps he could not escape his everyday chameleon exercises
in writing
for the theater), and poets have often fragmented their sensibilities
in
order to move in space and time.
What is different, though, in these two poets is how one strives for
the
certainty of the Enlightenment in his analysis of the human condition,
and
the other constructs meaning from the bricollage of consciousness -
thought
and feeling, and empirical textual markers - newspapers, diaries, oral
traditions...
While
Hibberd writes to
mark his own
territory,
Jordie Albiston moves into Browning’s - the representations
of
consciousnesses
at some other time and place removed from the poet’s, and in
The Ring and the Book,
to murder
and
its motivation and meaning. Albiston has chosen two murders: one by
Jean
Lee, and the other the state’s murder of her in the last
hanging of a
woman
in Australia in 1951. Like Browning’s epic, the poem is based
on
textual
remains, and Albiston’s poem is broken up into sections that
mimic its
newspaper
origins: Personal Pages, Entertainment Section, Crime Supplement, Death
Notices.
That is not to say that each poem reads like a text from a newspaper;
they
do not. In fact they cover many kinds of inscriptions: rhymes, school
reports, diary entries, direct to camera statements,
coroners’ reports;
but they all
purport to be some physical and direct textual remnant of Jean
Lee’s
life.
The narrative convention is that of the television documentary in which
actualité
is beefed up with
dramatizations,
speculations by others, and on-camera revelation. The style is spare
and
subtle, and the imagery direct and striking. Occasionally Jean
Lee’s
voice
sounds more like a radio drama of the time, at least to these ears,
which
though it makes sense in a way, sounds thin and trite at times. On
others,
Albiston gets the right register and makes her subject’s
voice move
away
from flat prose into the full weight of poetry - compare
‘Spring
Carnival
Fever’ with ‘Leaving Ray Brees’; in the
latter the nervous rhythms and
the heightened language movingly capture Jean’s impatience
and the
general war
fever of late 1939:
...It
seems
a
long way from here to the
Front
but the war’s
in my blood and
I simply can’t
feed Baby darn socks
work days be a
wife
while you do as
you please with our
life So that’s
me
I’m
done little Jill’s right
with
Mum and I’m
going AWOL tonight
Give it up
Honey
Hand in your gun
This War’s all
over and nobody won
What Albiston does well is tell the story economically and forcefully.
Although
Jean Lee’s life and crimes are given to us in a basically
chronological
sequence
(and there is a skeletal chronology at the beginning of the
collection),
Albiston has allowed her subject’s consciousness to move
around in
time,
building up to the pathetic climax of her hanging. The blend of direct
and
indirect narrative through real and imagined sources and revelation
from
Lee herself create a finely realized and sympathetic account of a
blighted
life. And there is the added benefit of some very moving and
intelligent poetry.
Back to top
New Writing
The
Hanging
of Jean Lee
David Wood
Imago, Vo.
11, No. 3, 1999
The Hanging of Jean Lee,
by
Jordie
Albiston, is poetry of an entirely different kind. Jean Lee, who
viciously
murdered William (Pop) Kent in 1949, was the last woman to be hanged in
Victoria.
Jordie Albiston’s work is a contemporary epic, a
danse macabre,
which haunts us with
its
moribund sentiments. It is Dorothy Porter, of course, who has brought
such
gothic tales centre stage in contemporary Australian poetry, appealing
with
verse both muscular and accessible. Although Jordie Albiston does not
parallel
Porter’s rhythmic verve, her collection is impressive on a
number of
other
accounts.
The first thing that impresses one about
The Hanging of Jean Lee
is its
elegance
and technical accomplishment: fifty-five individual poems effectively
hang
together to form an impressive whole. Jordie Albiston brings to these
poems
a highly refined sensibility, a deft poetic talent with a sensitive ear
for
cadence and tonal modulation. Her counterpoint of rhythms, some
cleverly
off-beat, can be strong and compelling:
I
stepped
off the overnight onto the payroll
of Lennons Hotel on
George served sass
and liquor in
appropriate rations to
General
MacArthur and his white
GI boys at
their
Brisbane watering-hole I
just had to
get
out of Sydney the
bastard wouldn’t
leave
me alone
‘Living it Up’
It is a pity that the collection does not climax more effectively. This
is
partly due to the fact that this small epic is not told strictly
chronologically,
to the moment of Lee’s hanging, partly because
Albiston’s technique
lacks
sufficient muscularity. The tale ends with a nursery rhyme:
She
is
dead she is dead says Peter to Robin
She is dead she is dead says Robin to Bobbin...
The Hanging of Jean Lee
is a
musical
collection of poems grim as Humperdinck’s
Hansel and Gretel.
It makes
engaging
reading from a poet of considerable insight and technical skill.
Back to top
Poetry as History
The
Hanging of
Jean
Lee
Dipti Saravanamuttu (poet)
Overland,
No. 156, Spring 1999
Opening this book is like opening a book of photographs - the poems are
instantly
both detailed and absorbing. Jordie Albiston’s third
collection of
poetry
is about the life and trial of Jean Lee, the last woman hanged in
Victoria.
Convicted, along with her lover Robert David Clayton,
‘Bobbie’, and a
third
male accomplice, of the torture and murder of William
‘Pop’ Kent in
November
1950, she was hanged in 1951. As a work of imaginative sympathy the
poems
sustain an emotional force and directness that one wonders if Albiston
would
allow herself if writing from her own persona. Certainly the poems
about
God are like this, but the poems about childhood, about marriage and
about
birth, are equally striking:
When
I
meet God I will
kill
Him With Bible
and knife I will cry for
His life in words even
He won’t he
willing to
fight
‘Dear Diary’
This book could be a who-dunnit, if one did not already know the ending
-
with the clues being literary ones, to be found in the early poems
about
childhood and adolescence, hinting as they do, of the existence of
violence,
and the role of law, and the law of the father. She dresses her dolls
‘for
a stroll / down streets lined with knives’ in material cut
from the
lamp
in the lounge:
O my
Lord
just you wait
till your father gets
home
You can’t do
as you please
whenever you
like
there’s
no room for children with
pincers for fingers in
this
house tonight
or any night
‘Sewing Hints’
It’s possible to suggest that the murder of Pop Kent is
synonymous with
the
murder of the principle of authority or the rule of law. And that the
symbolic
murder of the father (‘Pop’ Kent) betrays the wish
to substitute logic
and
sanity with their opposite, to replace these things with chaos, tyranny
and
cruelty.
These elements are there, and give the poems their strongly
metaphysical
undertones, despite their readabilily and apparent lightness. But
it’s
as
if the poets enters into the spirit and the mind of Jean Lee to such an
extent
that these elements are written in as opposites: if religious imagery
and
the hope of traditional religion are presented as a form of salvation
at
the end, so are they fearsome and threatening:
These
walls
are angels in their
hordes
families of
vampires
Vultures and harpies are the performers of religious rites in this poem:
A
couple
of
them sing to me we
will watch over
thee give me
communion in a medicine
cup
‘Cell Talk’
The angels are prison guards, ‘and angels / have taken Jean
under /
their
capable wings’ (‘Final Night’).
The book is constructed in rhymes and half rhymes, and employs constant
alliteration
with a dexterity unusual in a modern poet. This is quite a formalistic
book,
although a preoccupation with form is not to any degree a requirement
for
understanding and enjoying the poetry. The poems
‘unpack’ rather than
wear
their construction in an ornate or intrusive way.
The humour in these poems is not exactly caricature, rather, something
between
bleakness and whimsy, an odd unusual angle on life that is probably the
poet’s
best grace in dealing with her rather grim subject matter. This is a
very
carefully crafted book, and a highly intriguing one, not least because
it
calls into question ideas about the role of poetry as history: for
instance,
given that our interpretation of historical events is always to a
degree
subjective anyway, how valid a medium is poetry, to explain or analyze
the
underlying factors within significant events? If this book is anything
to
go by, poetry is an extremely capable medium, it would seem.
Back to top
Cities of body and mind
Barry Hill
The Weekend Australian,
28
August
1999
There is a pile of slim volumes growing on my desk and I have to
choose.
Among the better ones, three [Alex Skovron,
Infinite City,
Jack Hibberd,
The
Genius of Human Imperfection and
Jordie
Albiston,
The Hanging
of Jean Lee]
arrange themselves under the heading ‘City’ - the
city as body, mind
and
perhaps soul...
Crime is at the heart of Jordie Albiston’s city in
The Hanging of Jean Lee
because she
has
chosen to shadow the life of a murderer. The book comes with a flyer
that
gives the tabloid story of Lee who, with her pimp and standover
partner,
bashed an old SP bookie to death in Carlton in 1951. It seems to have
been
a crime that pushed the ugly mug of Melbourne into its own mirror.
Albiston is good on the idiom of the times, and the casual desperation
of
the down-beat characters who hung around bookies and pubs. It would
have
been tempting to become feminist-chic about Lee but the poems are too
well
tuned for that. The blank, suburban childhood, the slippage of life
chances,
the ultimately inexplicable murder, are well conveyed - their special
banality
highlighted.
As a whole, the book works in the mind like a novel, which is some
achievement
considering the spare poetry. Poem by poem, though, it is patchy, and
only
breaks out of its tabloid strongly in the poems about God. That is the
challenge
to which the book has only partially risen: how to tell a tabloid story
without
the tabloid murdering the art?
Back to top
Verse
in Review: Two Hands, Clapping...
The
Hanging
of
Jean
Lee
John Knight
Social Alternatives,
Vol. 18,
No. 3, July 1999 (pgs 81-82)
[Text not
yet available]
Back to top
Views & Reviews
Bev Braune
Heat, No.
12, Winter 1999
Judgements and confinement - personal and public - are the common
themes
of [Dorothy] Porter’s volume [
What a
Piece
of Work] and Jordie Albiston’s new collection,
The Hanging of Jean Lee,
where ‘God
/
is hurling angels down’ (‘Dear Diary
1951’).
Jean Lee was the last woman hanged in Australia, in 1951. She was
convicted
with Robert Clayton and Norman Andrews for murdering Pop Kent in
Victoria
in 1949.
The Hanging of
Jean Lee
opens with a chronology of Jean Lee: from her marriage on 28 July 1903
to
her hanging on 19 February 1951. Albiston’s acknowledgments
include
reference
to Wilson, Lincoln and Treble’s Jean Lee:
The Last Woman Hanged in
Australia
and
archival source material used in composing her book. As well, the
publishers
include a photocopied extract from a
Herald
article (March 28, 1951) on the Jean Lee case - her Catholic school
education,
her factory jobs, her taking up with Clayton, ‘underworld
sniveller and
prostitutes’ gentleman’, to street-walking and
finally to robbery and
murder. Albiston
has organised her interpretation of Lee’s life in a
refracting series
of
multiple voices - reportage by Lee’s family, newspapers, the
autopsy
report
on Pop Kent, and Lee’s Dr Jekyll-and-Mr Hyde voice (even
after we have
come
to accept, as readers, that she is dead).
Judgement - and confinement - is a subject which characterises some of
the
best literature of this century - Franz Kafka’s
Die Verwantlung,
Jack Mapanje’s
Skipping
Without Ropes, Anna
Akhmatova’s
Selected Poems,
David
Constantine’s
Caspar Hauser
and Kamau
Brathwaite’s
Middle Passage
trilogy.
Porter’s
and Albiston’s books foreground human realities as part of
their
critical
assessments of the ‘form’ side of imprisonment,
that is, the physical
and
experiential machinations of confinement. For, as Ryle would have
argued,
you cannot speak about people’s minds without speaking about
their
physical
world; to do so is to comply with the Descartes’ category
mistake, to
regard
mind and body as separate spheres of existence.
Institutions come and go - the Soviet Union, Callan Park Hospital for
the
Insane. Capital punishment in Australia no longer exists; Pentridge
Prison
does. But in the minds of those who suffered under such systems either
as
the warders or the prisoners or those writing about either, the worlds
of
constraint are alive as ever, as Albiston so effectively conveys in
relating
the events Jean Lee’s life. As Lee’s teacher is
reported to have said
of
her: ‘she seems / to reside quite a lot in her
head’. And as Lee’s
voice
confirms:
But
how I wish I
was
out with
my
Dad
on the Chase in our worn wooden
boat
My cocoon
quietly hardens You’re
drifting
away I’m
going inside I
dread this
‘Dear Diary (c.
1931)’
The theme of the restricted woman, that territory of real, imprisoned
lives,
is Albiston’s singular interest in her published collections
to date.
Her
first collection,
Nervous
Arcs
(1995)
opened, not surprisingly, with: ‘I am a woman locked in a /
room in a
house
in a / suburb/ you could call me / some kind of princess / though the
only
spinning / done is in my head / this is / my industry.’
Whereas in
Porter’s
book we view the world through the gaoler’s eyes, in
Albiston’s it is
that
of the gaoled. We are reminded in both volumes that there is some
little
difference between the
experiences
of gaoler and gaoled.
This new volume brings into sharp focus the question of the possibly
indispensable
false judgement of the last woman to be hanged in Australia: Lee was
morally
corrupt (a ‘bad’ woman), would have come to a
‘bad’ end and was
therefore
rightfully convicted for murder and for being morally corrupt. There
seems
no doubt that Lee had a hand in the murder of Pop Kent. It is the
judgement
of Lee as an ‘unrespectable woman’ that has
captured Albiston’s
imagination.
This element gives real substance to Lee’s voice, her anger
against God
and
her desire for absolution from social confinement such that physical
confinement allows her ‘space’ for mental freedom,
at least the space
where Albiston
convinces us that Lee can be free -‘in her head’.
Albiston’s uses overt and covert
caesura
which worked to some extent in
Nervous
Arcs
and
Botany
Bay
Document (1996). Here she has taken the poetic
form, and the
theme
of bondage, further than a contemplation of the isolated woman, in the
suburbs
or as a convict, to the study of an historical figure who indulged in
acts
of sexual bondage as a prostitute and was a convicted murderer. It will
be interesting to see if Albiston will be able to break free of the
compelling
mid-line and end-line
casurae
form
which dominates her poetry. In
The
Hanging
of Jean Lee she has been able to draw a balance between
the
objective
and subjective by manipulating form to her advantage, exemplified by
‘Mug
Shot I’, ‘Dear Diary (1941)’,
‘You Stalker’, ‘In Defence of the Working
Girl’,
‘Note to a ‘daughter’ and ‘The
Hangman’s Handbook.’
I tie
her
carefully to
the
chair that she
may feel held as
she
falls Adjust
the hood and get
the
nod then let
the trapdoor go
If Jean Lee had lived twenty years later, she might have been a patient
under
the ‘care’ of a Peter Cyren [
What a
Piece
of Work] - the evidence of Dorothy Porter’s
powerful book leaves
me
feeling that such a fate would have been worse than hanging.
Back to top
The Hanging
of
Jean
Lee
Bernadette Power
New England Review,
No. 10,
Winter 1999 (pgs 18-20)
[Text not yet available]
Back to top
Dangerous Women
The
Hanging
of
Jean
Lee
Ron Pretty
Scarp, No.
34, June 1999 (pgs
67-68)
[Text
not yet available]
Back to top
Poetry
A Grim And Rough Story
The
Hanging of
Jean
Lee
Dorothy Hewett (author)
Australian Book Review,
No.
210,
May 1999
The Hanging of Jean Lee
is the
third
verse novel I have reviewed recently, except that this one is closer to
the
verse documentary. As one might expect, it is a grim, tough story of
the
deterioration of a young woman’s life and its brutal end. It
is divided
into
four sections with deliberately cold-hearted titles, Personal Pages,
Entertainment
Section, Crime Supplement and Death Notices.
The Hanging of Jean Lee
is
economically
and imaginatively conceived with a strong narrative drive. In a series
of
short connected poems, Jordie Albiston has made a heart-breaker out of
her
material, ringing the verse changes, using rhyme and blank verse in
short
chopped lines, colloquial language, reportage and newspaper headlines
with
considerable skill.
Jean Lee was born in Dubbo in 1919, the daughter of a railway man.
Later
the family shifted to Chatswood, ‘a normal family in a normal
house in
a
normal suburb on Sydney’s north shore’. Yet it took
Jean only fifteen
years
to reach the gallows, the last woman to be hanged in Pentridge jail. An
attractive,
lively redhead, she attended a Catholic school, passed her
intermediate,
and began moving from factory job to factory job, all well below her
intelligence
level. She married at eighteen but it ended only a year later, leaving
her
with a baby daughter and ‘a trail of rent bills from Redfern
to Glebe’.
What
a
waste of a wedding.
What a fool of a bloke!
With the outbreak of World War II, she becomes ‘a
soldier’s girl’:
Call
me
yank lover
cunt to my face.
It doesn’t take her long to graduate into prostitution.
This
is
work and as far as I can see
You wanna touch? You
wanna feel?
You wanna pay the lonely
man’s fee.
Her lover and pimp is Robert Clayton, a well known petty crim,
embezzler,
housebreaker and drunk roller. She calls him ‘her
Bobbie’. In the
underworld
of Sydney, Perth, and eventually Melbourne, she is known as Skinny
Jean.
Together they work the streets, cheap rooms and pubs, Jean as decoy,
Bobbie
as standover man and blackmailer.
He
calls
us Bonnie and Clyde.
He thinks we have their
kind of style.
Their criminal career ends with a brutal murder. With the help of an
accomplice,
they torture and strangle an elderly Carlton bookmaker during race week
in
Melbourne. The victim is left with his nasal bones fractured, a tennis
ball
cheek, a dinnerplate thigh, cigarette burns, a broken bottle slashed in
his
face, dents to his head and his larynx garrotted by hand.
How then to transform Jean Lee, this sleazy cold-hearted whore, into a
figure
fit for human sympathy? Albiston uses Lee’s days in solitary
confinement
waiting for death as a vehicle for a series of passionate interior
monologues
of considerable strength and energy. With Jean Lee alone in the
condemned
cell, God doesn’t answer but some tatty angels do rustle in.
Hark
the Herald angels sing
Jean Lee
is going to die They
lick their
tacky tabloid wings
It isn’t so long ago, 1951, since Jean Lee was hanged. We are
left with
a
horror for the whole brutal proceedings of capital punishment and grief
for
the wasted life of a beautiful young woman. Quite an achievement.
Fly
Away
Jean
A flurry of feathers and
she’s off
leaving
the chair and the rope
and the press
and
the
bleeding hearts lined
up outside Ding
dong she’s
flown the coop and the
crowd
has heard the clang They
raise their
faces
to the sky while all
over Melbourne
the
morning stars and
mothers call
children
to
their sides to cover
their innocent
eyes
She is dead she is dead says Peter to Robin
She is dead she is dead says Robin to Bobbin
She is dead she is dead says John all alone
She is dead she is dead says everyone
Why is it then that I am left so dissatisfied with the verse novel in
general
and why this fascination with a particular genre, apparently growing in
popularity?
Is it an attempt to bridge the gap between prose and poetry, to create
a
new popular audience? Maybe it works well for those who are willing to
accept
poetry only as an offshoot to narrative, but inevitably it seems to me
that
this strong narrative drive must eventually dictate the style. The
result
is a tendency towards a flattening of diction, a uniformity of tone,
that
it seems difficult in the long run to transcend (unless by the
considerable skill of a Les Murray).
I don’t want a poetry that is made easy. I long for the
magical flash
of
insight, the rhythmic stanzas that sing, the intellectual fascination
of
decoding what is difficult. In other words the whole lyrical
transcendental
impulse of poetry.
Back to top
Characters of Life
The
Hanging of
Jean
Lee
Gig Ryan (poet)
The Age, 17
April 1999
Jean Lee was the last woman hanged in Victoria, in 1951, along with two
male
cohorts for the murder of a Carlton SP bookie. There were no more
hangings
until 1967. Jordie Albiston’s third book consists of an
ambitious
series
of monologues in the voice of Lee interspersed with newspaper reports
of
the crime and trial.
Stepping
the narrow sparrow-lit alleyways
wash-slopped
cobblestones a steeling
sky
brick walls hopscotched
with stale
ivy
vines
and out on to Lygon...
These monologues, from childhood to scene-of-the-crime, never entirely
jell:
the happy-go-lucky crim flirting with US soldiers in Sydney, the
childhood
in Dubbo, the murder in Melbourne. The language is jaunty, at times
sounding
like Alan Wearne’s poetry:
...the
sound
of your oars
at last reaching a shore
where you’ve
more than your basic
Buckley’s at
love?
O my boasters! my boys!
The last section, Death Notices, is the most varied and convincing and
Lee
here becomes a flesh-and-blood character making diary notes in
‘Dear
Diary
1951’ ‘God is / looking down on me with eyes / as
large as psalms’ and
pondering
her fate in ‘Solitary’.
Soulless
territory I know self
on self on shadows flung
weakly
down from the tiny bulb
clamped
to the Pentridge sky...
...till the angels
arrive clanging
their wings like
rubbish-bin
lids
to herald the
morning in
But there is little suspense or explanation. Lee’s character
seems
intermittently
bland, religious, superficial but strangely not tragic and
Albiston’s
insistent
rhythm and rhyme seem at odds with the subject.
This book does what it intends, calling Lee and capital punishment
(abolished
in Victoria, 1975) to our attention, but Lee remains somehow incomplete.
Back to top
Murderess
portrayed in verse
The
Hanging of
Jean
Lee
Edward Reilly
Geelong Advertiser,
10 April
1999
Jean Lee’s life lasted a mere 32 years. She was born the
daughter of a
Dubbo
railroad worker in 1919, had a Catholic, schooling, and seemed destined
for
a mundane life.
But not Jean. Older readers may remember the screaming heading in the
Herald of March 28,
1951, ‘Portrait
of
a Murder ess’. This article, the basis of
Albiston’s fictive recreation
of
Lee’s life, outlines how Lee at 16, ‘a trim, tender
girl with a gay,
provocative
smile, wiry red hair’ was restless.
Within two years she had made a hasty marriage, ‘a hopeless
match from
the
stars’, the
Herald
reporter
breathlessly
informed its readers. Soon after, she was found to be
‘frankly
practising’
the ancient red-light trade. Het pimp, Robert Clayton, encouraged Lee
to
‘get her clients drunk’, and at some time in the
early hours, Clayton
and
an accomplice would roll the John, sometimes not so gently.
Jean Lee was not a nice gal and she came ultimately to a gruesome end,
the
last woman in Victoria to be executed.
Where the
Herald
tells a
story
like Jean Lee’s as a black and white morality tale, Jordie
Albiston is
far
more understanding of Lee both as a sinner and as someone greatly
sinned
against.
Albiston traces Lee’s fall from grace in four stages:
-‘Personal Pages’
-
her early innocent life; ‘Entertainment. Section’ -
early marriage and
learning
the trade, ‘Crime Supplement’ - an account of the
criminal life and the
killing
of William (Pop) Kent; and finally, the self-explanatory
‘Death
Notices’.
Each stage consists of 14 or so one-page poems, many of which are
written
in Lee’s voice: occasionally Albiston, as narrator,
intervenes. These
poems
are strong, and well-written. They have an immediate force and I
greatly
enjoyed the range of textures of the various poems.
But what I liked most of all about
The
Hanging of Jean Lee was its ability to recapture a sense
of the
times.’
I can remember the screaming headlines and Lee’s face staring
out of
the
Adelaide
News
front page. The
cut
of her double-breasted coat was smart, like those featured in the
Women’s Weekly
fashion pages
scattered
on my mother’s workbench.
Certainly my parents knew of Jean Lee and her Sydney escapades before
she
‘turned bad’, as it was put in those days. And
there was some sympathy
amongst
the local women: most of them thought Judge Duffy was too harsh in
applying
the law. Was he looking for a knighthood? Bad enough that Ned Kelly had
been
‘stretched’, but to do that to a woman was
considered to be little more
than
judicial murder.
This is Jordie Albiston’s third, and strongest, book of
poetry so far.
It
gains strength from two factors, both of which are missing from many
contemporary
Australian poets’ work. Firstly, she is not afraid of formal
verse, the
poems
flowing in ordered stanzas of three, four or six lines and clear
rhythmic
structures. The images are potent and fresh, and as the book nears its
climax,
Albiston invests her doomed heroine with a tough energy which
underlines
each verse.
The Hanging of Jean Lee
is
strongly
recommended as an engrossing and forceful read.
Back to top
The
strange life of Jean Lee
Geoff Page
Panorama,
The Canberra
Times,
10
April 1999
On February 19, 1951, Jean Lee became the last women to be hanged in
Australia.
This verse biography by Melbourne poet Jordie Albiston is an attempt to
make
sense of how Marjorie Wright, a relatively ‘normal’
girl brought up in
Chatswood
could end up as the prostitute and murderer Jean Lee, hanged in
Pentridge.
Using contemporary press clippings (many of them collected in an
earlier
book,
Jean Lee: The
Last Women
Hanged in
Australia) Albiston has written 55 poems tracing Jean
Lee’s
trajectory
from a slightly strange but ‘promising’ schoolgirl
through to an
unsatisfactory
marriage at 18, the birth of a daughter (subsequently left to
Lee’s
mother
to raise), an unsuccessful career in a number of jobs, her entry into
the
company of pimps and petty criminals in Brisbane and Perth during World
War
II, her collaboration in the murder of an SP bookmaker in 1949 and her
eventual execution.
Most of the poems are written from Lee’s viewpoint but,
perhaps
disconcertingly,
a number are written from that of an omniscient narrator or from the
point
of view of other key figures such as her primary school teacher and her
hangman.
While the latter do help to ‘fill out the picture’
they also diminish
the
claustrophobic intensity that might have been achieved if the reader
had
been confined to Jean Lee’s head throughout. It’s
interesting that in
another
current and popular verse narrative, Dorothy Porter’s
What a Piece of Work,
we never
escape
from the first-person narrator’s obsessions.
As with Albiston’s previous book,
Botany
Bay Document, the poet uses metrical verse which has been
deliberately
‘roughened’ into uneven line lengths with buried
rhymes. This is an
interesting
technique, and one which Albiston might reasonably call her own, but it
does
not work equally well in all poems. Traditional metres and rhymes set
up
firm expectations which are interestingly, and often frustratingly,
denied.
Much of the verse is anapaestic, unusual in the 20th century, but
strongly
reminiscent of the poetic (and sometimes doggerel-like) broadsheets
sold
for a penny or so at London’s 18th century execution grounds.
As with these earlier balladic spin-offs from hangings
Albiston’s book
has
a curious kind of moral ambivalence. While it mostly laments the
ill-fatedness
of Jean Lee’s life, it also rejoices in the adventure of her
life and
at
times seems to endorse the central character’s moral
shortsightedness.
References
to the murder of SP book-maker ‘Pop’ Kent are cut
into the otherwise
chronological
stream of events. These pull no punches about her contribution to the
killing
(which included torturing Kent with a lit cigarette) but the poem,
‘An
Explanation
of Sorts’, does suggest that Lee was somehow repaying Kent
symbolically
(and,
of course, unfairly) for all the maltreatment she had suffered at the
hands
of men during her life - and particularly during her more recent years
as
a prostitute: ‘...and Pop / was the man who stood for those
years / of
wandering
hands and laughed-at / dreams and branches catching at
threads’.
Whether or not
The
Hanging of Jean
Lee
solves, once and for all, the psychological problem of why Lee
committed
the murder remains to be seen. The book certainly succeeds, however,
mainly
through its original poetic technique, in creating a sense of
Lee’s
humanity
and making most of us glad that the incredibly simple-minded punishment
of
‘hanging by the neck until dead’ has not been
practised in this country
since
1967.
Back to top
The Hanging of Jean Lee
Shane Rowlands
Meanjin,
Vol. 57, No. 4, 1998
Part discontinuous narrative poem and part poetic biography, Jordie
Albiston’s
third book,
The Hanging
of Jean Lee,
is about the last woman hanged in Australia. The fifty-five poems in
this
collection become the blood, nerve and muscle of the skeletal
chronology
(included after the contents pages) of Lee’s life, which
culminates
with
her hanging in 1951.
Dead at thirty-one, Lee’s short life was dogged by grief,
depression,
violence,
alcoholism and petty crime. Born in 1919 in Dubbo, the youngest of five
kids,
Lee grew up
In a
normal
family in a normal
home in a normal suburb
on
Sydney’s north
shore
‘A Chatswood Chapter’
Her ‘normal’ was being pregnant at fourteen and
forced to give her baby
up
for adoption. By the time she was twenty-one, Lee had left a violent
marriage
and abandoned her second child, Jillian, when she moved to Brisbane to
escape
continued stalking and harassment from her ex-husband Raymond Brees.
After meeting pimp Morris Dias, Lee began working as a prostitute,
travelling
from Brisbane to Perth. Later, when Lee and convicted criminal Bobby
Clayton
became lovers, she continued to do sex work, often acting as the sexual
bait
in the ‘badger game’, Clayton’s ruse for
fleecing other men. One of
these
games backfired in Melbourne in November 1949, when Lee, Clayton and
Norman
Andrews attempted to rob an elderly bookie, Pop Kent, who was found
beaten
and murdered. While there were strong suggestions that Lee did not
participate
in Kent’s murder and that the cops forced a false confession
from her,
Albiston chooses not to dwell on these injustices or to construct Lee
simplistically
as an innocent victim. Her approach is one of neither flashy
sensationalism
nor soppy lyricism.
In handling the delicate matter of a real person’s life,
Albiston’s
work
is characterised by humility, respect and compassion, avoiding the
potential
pitfalls of working with biographical and historical material.
The Hanging of Jean Lee
does not
fall
prey to the deterministic thinking of cause and effect or the
compulsion
to explain a life neatly by reducing it to a significant event. A
number
of poems dealing with Jean as a child and an adolescent prefigure the
murder
and Jean’s imprisonment and death. Often ironic, these omens
suggest a
fatedness,
as is the case in ‘School Report (1928)’ with its
primary teacher’s
concluding
remarks about Jean, who
Is a
girl
of obvious promise and handled
with
care she may
yet make her mark
in
the annals of this
hopeful young
nation
However, Albiston is clear that any sense of destiny is constructed by
readers,
poet and Lee herself in hindsight:
People
get
vague about the pre-press years
though you can turn this
to your own
favour
You alone remember
why and how
you
changed
Never write
any of it down
The moment occurs as it
must if you
look
it reads handle with
care but then
you
forget
and when you remember
it’s
gone You
say
living is for feeling
what it is like
to
be alive and
draw a bad hand
‘Note to a Daughter’
In her evocations of Jean Lee, Albiston is scrupulous in avoiding
anachronisms.
A meticulous researcher, she has a thorough understanding and sure
grasp
of the broader socio-historical context, economic conditions and
significant
public events, and makes dexterous use of this in many poems. In
‘Leaving
Ray Brees’, World War II informs ‘the modern
artillery of the marital
military’
and the breakdown of Lee’s marriage. The space to be embraced
by ‘the
unfinished
arms’ of the Harbour Bridge undergoing construction (and
officially
opened
in 1932) becomes a space in nine-year-old Jean’s head in
which she
daydreams about ‘a sky full of / future before her wandering
feet’ (‘A
Chatswood Chapter’).
Albiston does not mistake or overstate the so-called ‘hard
evidence’-
including
press coverage, photographs (mug shots and studio portraits), police,
court
and prison files - as factual. Drawing on this kind of documentation in
a
number of poems, she highlights it as partial truths open to multiple
interpretations.
While I found the newspaper reports the least interesting pieces in the
collection,
they are crucial in the inspired structuring of the book’s
four
sections:
‘Personal Pages’, ‘Entertainment
Section’, ‘Crime Supplement’ and
‘Death
Notices’. There are many similarities between the somewhat
perverse
pleasures
of reading (and writing?) these particular sections of newspapers and
the territories of biography.
In
The Silent Woman,
her
brilliant
meditation on the Sylvia Plath biographical industry, Janet Malcolm
observes:
Biography
is the medium through which the remaining secrets of the famous dead
are
taken from them and dumped out in full view of the world... The
voyeurism
and busybodyism that impel writers and readers of biography alike are
obscured
by an apparatus of scholarship designed to give the enterprise an
appearance
of banklike blandness and solidi ... the more [the
biographer’s] book
reflects
his industry the more the reader believes that he is having an
elevating
literary experience, rather than simply listening to backstairs gossip
and
reading other people’s mail.
In
The Hanging of Jean
Lee,
Albiston
explores the poetics of biography, and because her subject was, and to
some
extent still is, a demonised woman, Albiston excavates and elaborates
biographical
moments in order to rehumanise Jean. Her project is not so much a
matter
of exposing Lee’s secrets as it is about inventing them in
order to
reclaim
some sense of her inner.life.
In order to hear Jean’s many voices in a range of registers,
volumes,
rhythms
and intonations during the various stages of her life, many poems are
written
in the first person. The line breaks and stanzas in
‘Mum’s Little
Helper’
immediately conjure up a four-year-old’s awkward stop-start
phrasing as
if
learning to read. In ‘Dear Diary (1934)’, Jean -
post-adoption and
brazen
with grief - writes ‘When I meet God I will / kill
Him.’ Albiston’s
risk-taking
imagery of Jean deifying herself as an angel of vengeance and God
casting
Himself as pitiful sinner at her feet resists repathologising Lee as
evil
and delusional. By ‘Crime Supplement’, however,
Jean’s voice has
hardened,
her dreams have been squashed. In ‘Death Notices’,
her voice has been
swallowed
up by the living death of solitary confinement and the incomprehensible
terror
and loneliness of abandonment by her family. Albiston’s
bio-mythography
works
to restore emotional complexity and some sense of resistance to Jean
Lee’s
life.
Back to top
Rebecca
Edwards
Don’t Play
Games, I Want to Be Woken Up
Linq, Vol.
25, No. 2, October
1998
The Hanging of Jean Lee,
by
Jordie
Albiston, is a re-creation of certain pivotal incidents in the life of
the
last woman to be hanged in Australia. Lee’s voice develops,
in the
rhythms
of 40s swing, from an earnest four year-old, to soldier’s
good-time
girl,
to hardened prostitute capable of murder. The steady, journalistic
inevitability
is broken, powerfully, by Lee’s cry to the God who has
forsaken her: ‘I
will
teach Him the scriptures from inside of me’ (Dear Diary 1934).
There is nothing moralistic about Albiston’s unfurling of
Lee’s
character.
Why, and how, she became hardened enough to stub out cigarettes in an
old
man’s chest, is hinted at, rather than imaginatively
‘explained’. This
left
me unsatisfied on the first reading. I wanted Albiston to dive in, away
from
‘the facts’, to make a solid if fictional
connection between an early
and
a later event. When I went back to the book a second time, however, I
found
that it simply flowed, that everything was
right; the slightly
jangly rhythms,
the
shifts between newspaper reportage and Lee’s voice, the
juxtaposition
of
‘past’ (Lee’s childhood and youth) and
‘now’ (her imprisonment and
execution).
The seamless narrative opens to explore, with great subtlety,
Lee’s
development
as both recipient and perpetrator of atrocities in a place and time
which failed to ‘handle her with care’ (see
‘School Report (1928)’).
I am grateful for Albiston’s restraint, for the delicate
sense of
timing
with which she places a poem like ‘In Defence of the Working
Girl’ very
soon
after ‘Dear Diary (1941)’. This is a book that will
‘make its mark’, in
a
more positive sense than its subject.
Back to top
Review
The
Hanging of
Jean
Lee
Wayne Atherton
In this, her third published collection of poems, Australian poet
Jordie
Albiston has construed a 55 poem biographical chronology of Marjorie
Jean
Maude Wright, a.k.a. Jean Lee: a woman convicted (along with two men)
of
a murder and sentenced to hang. As such, Lee is known to be the last
woman
hanged in Australia.
The poems begin with Lee’s birth in 1919 and end with her
death on the
gallows
in 1951. Alternating between first and third person perspective, these
poems
effectively capture the protagonist’s bitterly tragic story
of sullen,
loveless
rage. Albiston’s language flows. Often darkly limerick, these
poems
engage
the tongue and occasionally offer up regionally-flavored dialect:
Dulcie’s
up the fig
Tree sulking from a smack
For nicking
Florie’s fancy
Dib and hiding it out
back
Reading this collection, one may be reminded of the Dillinger series of
poems
by American poet Todd Moore. Jean Lee could also be thought of as
Bonnie
for a similar though distinctly Australian Bonnie and Clyde saga. From
the
poem, ‘In Defence of the Working Girl’:
This
is
work and as far as I see
You wanna
touch?
You wanna feel?
You wanna pay the lonely
man’s fee
Back to top
Launch
Speeches
Alison
Croggon
(poet)
‘On every side,’ says Germaine Greer in
The Whole Woman,
‘speechless women
endure
endless hardship, grief and pain, in a world system that creates
billions
of losers for every handful of winners. It’s time to get
angry again.’
Jordie
Albiston didn’t need to read this to get angry.
The Hanging of Jean Lee
is a book
of
rage.
Jean Lee was one of the losers, and she lost big time. The final months
of
her life were spent in solitary confinement in Pentridge, waiting to be
hanged
for the murder, with two male accomplices, of an old man, Pop Kent. She
was
the last woman hanged in Victoria.
Lee is not simply a victim. Albiston tells, in her extraordinary
narrative
sequence, a story which doesn’t fit such easy categorisation.
Jean Lee
is
a woman full of pain, resentment and hatred which, as Albiston tells it
in
‘An Explanation of Sorts’, explodes in murderous
rage:
and
that’s
why I did him that
old meat pie
Pop
That’s why I did him
Saved it all up and
settled the score
in
his own shabby Dorrit St
shop
The complexity of the anger which afflicts her is evoked in a sequence
in
which Albiston uses a mixture of ballad forms and nursery rhymes to
tell
the story of Lee’s life, from her birth to her death. She
creates a
startling
complexity out of apparent simplicity. The poetry is forged from a
vivid,
vernacular language, and skilled collages of contemporary documents -
headlines,
police reports, documents of prison. It is a tribute to the achievement
of
Albiston’s poetic that she has made poems capable of being
tough,
funny,
tragic, beautiful, sad, desperate, and pregnant with vivid realism: not
once
do they slip into the sentimental or the banal. Jean Lee’s
spiky,
uncomfortable
ghost rises and is made real.
But, despite her portrayal of this angry, tragic woman, the major
effect
of this book is the sorrow behind the rage: the waste of a bright,
rebellious
woman’s life, which becomes emblematic of a larger waste.
This book is lyric poetry of a high order, but you need to read it to
find
that out. I recommend it unreservedly.
Back to top
John
Leonard (anthologist)
There is a story I haven’t been able to confirm in the last
week,
concerning
the two great classical poets Tu Fu and Li Po. The story is that, after
a
night of drinking together and writing, they went outside where it had
been
raining and made little paper boats out of their poems and launched
them
down the flowing gutters of the street.
This is an example of ‘It seemed a good idea at the
time’; and also of
ironic
hope. But who can tell? After many centuries, lovers of poetry are
reading
Li Po and Tu Fu. The story may not be historical but it has a poetical
truth.
It reminds me that I am not launching this book tonight: Jordie
Albiston
is doing that herself, with the intentness of those poets bending over
the
water. My role is to speak some words of high praise, which I do
unstintingly.
This book of 71 pages is a large book, a good deal larger than many
novels
in its scope. It’s about the life of Jean Lee. Each of its 55
lyrics is
an
event in that life, from childhood to her death - and cumultatively,
because
of the compression of poetry the effect is large and full: so much
variety
of circumstance and act and mood and coping and passion. The title is
an
uncompromising one for your bookshelves:
The Hanging of Jean Lee.
Jean Lee,
to
explain briefly, was one of those people who between them tortured,
bashed,
killed and robbed a man named Pop Kent in a fit of drunken chaos in a
house
in Carlton in 1949.
The details of what happened are not fully known. There were some
breaches
of law and due process in the interrogations and trial. All three were
hanged,
and Jean Lee is notable as the last woman to be hanged in Australia.
Jordie Albiston is a historian as well as a poet. She wrote a Ph.D on
the
Salem witch trials, and her previous book of poetry was
Botany
Bay Document,
a series of lyrics which imagine the experience of women in early
colonial
NSW.
For a poet such as Jordie Albiston, truth particularly means integrity.
As
in
Botany
Bay
Document, her imaginative understanding is
strongly directed
towards
a fellow woman. These poems enhance understanding of a woman such as
Jean
Lee very richly, yet they excuse nothing. This is difficult to achieve,
since
imaginative understanding is a two-way movement between our own lives
and
those of others: we are at stake ourselves in the reading of such
poetry.
This is an uncompromising book. It has an extraordinary sense of lives
lived.
These poems, like all the best poetry, are full of liveliness and quiet.
And they are poetry. The more often I read these poems, the more
complex
appears the world that they open; and the more I am aware, simply, of
poems.
Jordie’s mastery of rhythm is of the highest order. Her poems
take you
up
into an unstoppable movement forward with their irregular runs of
four-beat
triple rhythm, able to be varied at will - to be slowed, to be shifted
momentarily
into a different rhythm, and then return. I don’t know of
anything in
the
language which uses this rhythm so flexibly. These poems look good on
the
page, but see where they lead you when you read them aloud.
A final remark. I don’t often come across a book where, as a
reader, I
find
no poems on passages or lines that could have been left out or further
edited.
This is that rare book. For all its richness, it is lean. Also: Jordie
was
able to point out to me something that I hadn’t noticed -
that even the
two
‘Reportage’ poems, which are found poems, made of
quotations from
newspaper
reports in
The Sun
and
The Argus,
are shaped into form and
rhymed,
or at least half-rhymed, with no word altered. I recommend this book.
Back to top
Sydney Opera
House Performance

A new opera was
performed at the Sydney Opera House based on The Hanging of Jean Lee
by Jordie Albiston, on 2 - 6 August 2006. It was presented at The
Studio at the Sydney Opera House in association with Green Room Music.
A daring new music-theatre work that traces the grim life of the last
woman to be hanged in Australia in 1951 and the trajectory of her
thoughts as she approaches execution. Based on Jordie
Albiston’s verse biography of the same name and featuring a
stellar cast of Australian talent, this is a retro-indie post-punk
musical, mashing up forms as diverse as the biographic documentary,
rock concerts, performance text and pop videos. Andrée
Greenwell’s score evokes a dark, seedy underground, exposing
raw
emotions to create a gritty edge, before the musical slips into an
underworld of tragedy, horror and fantasy..
Andrée Greenwell – Composer, Artistic Director
Max Sharam – Jean Lee
Jeff Duff - Performer
Josh Quong Tart - Performer
Hugo Race – Performer
Jordie Albiston and Abe Pogos - Script
Tim Maddock – Director
Dan Potra - Designer
Anna Messariti - Producer
Back to top
O’Hearn Fellow
draws her poetry from
history
Melbourne UniNews,
Vol. 6, No.
12,
11 April 1997
Jordie Albiston stands in Dorrit Street - a slight figure in a long
black
coat. It’s a normal working day and the little Carlton street
is lined
with
parked cars.
Jordie’s attention is focussed on a tall, handsome house
across the
road.
With its balcony featuring arches and columns, it stands out above its
humble
single-storey neighbours.
But Jordie Albiston is not in the house market. She wants to see the
house
because it’s part of a story she’s writing. Nearly
50 years ago, it was
the
scene of a murder - a murder which resulted in the hanging of Jean Lee,
the
last woman to be hung in Victoria.
Jordie Albiston is writing a documentary poem,
The Hanging of Jean Lee.
In a
series
of short poems - written in newspaper-style columns with
newspaper-style
headings - it’s a chronology of Jean Lee’s life
from birth to death.
This work is being supported by Jordie Albiston’s appointment
as the
1997
Dinny O’Hearn Fellow in the University’s Australian
Centre.
While the biennial Dinny O’Hearn Fellowship is offered to a
writer yet
to
become established, Jordie Albiston - chosen from a field of 68
applicants
- is well on the way.
She has been writing seriously for about 10 years, while taking out an
Arts
degree and a PhD in literature at La Trobe University. The juggling of
responsibilities
continues. Now three jobs and the demands of two teenage children
compete
for the time she can devote to writing.
Her documentary poetry is non-fictional, based on documentary materials
and
even has a bibliography. It brings together Jordie’s
fascination with
history
and her interest in writing poetry.
Jordie has had two books of poetry published, and has won international
acclaim.
Her first collection of poetry
Nervous
Arcs caused writer Janette Turner Hospital to comment on
Jordie’s
‘sharp intelligence, lyrical grace and moral passion. A name
to watch
for’.
Jordie’s second collection,
Botany
Bay
Document; A Poetic History of the Women of Botany Bay, is
a
documentary
poetry charting the first 50 years of settlement at Botany Bay and Port
Jackson
through the eyes of various women.
She is also published widely in literary journals and magazines, has
performed
her work on international television, and her poetry has been read on
radio.
In 1991 she was awarded the Wesley Michel Wright National Poetry Prize
and
in 1994 the Premier’s Poetry Award in Queensland.
Jordie Albiston has no plans to glorify Jean Lee. She points out very
matter-of-factly
that Jean Lee and her lover committed the brutal murder of an SP bookie
named
Pop Kent, but that as the last woman hung in Victoria she has claimed a
place
in our history.
‘This was just after the Second World War and as she was a
single
mother
and a prostitute, there’s a feeling that she was hanged tas
an example
to
women,’ she points out.
Usually Jordie has to spend months researching in libraries gathering
material
for her documentary poems. In this case, she’s been extremely
fortunate
to
have access to archival material researched by Don Treble, one of the
authors
of a recent book on Jean Lee.
But if readers are expecting
The
Hanging
of Jean Lee to be a dry factual account, Jordie points out
that
she
has still taken poetic licence, particularly as a lot of facts about
Jean
Lee’s early life are missing.
Jordie Albiston will be working on
The
Hanging of Jean Lee at the Australian Centre a couple of
days a
week
over the next few months. The Dinny O’Hearn Fellowship, she
says, gives
her
a place to work and some money to support the project. She will also
give
some seminars and readings of her poetry.
The Hanging of Jean Lee
is to
be
published next year by Black Pepper.
Back to top